I thought I would hold back my thoughts on a couple of movies Noel and I recently saw, thanks to the WGA, until it was a bit closer to their release, but since reviews have started popping up, including ones from Variety and The Hollywood Reporter, I decided I wouldn't be jumping the gun by putting my mini-reviews here.
I AM LEGEND
I saw a WGA screening of the new Will Smith movie, I Am Legend, based on the Richard Matheson novel. The book has been adapted before, into Last Man On Earth as well as Omega Man.
Although the movie doesn't have a whole lot to do with the novel this is an adaptation so frankly I think it's best to forget the book and just accept it on its own terms. And as I was watching I was going, "Oh, God. This is incredible. This is the best Will Smith performance ever and I've liked him in many films. How did they do THAT? Oh, God. I've never seen anything like this before." I was so there.
For 2/3rds of the movie.
And then something happened. What was so incredible, so mind-numbing, so I-can't-believe-they-can-do-that, suddenly falls apart. The last third of the movie just doesn't work, least not the way the first 2/3rds did. I also feel the movie is missing an entire major beat just before the final scene because the ending seems to be too abrupt.
I don't want to go on because I think what I Am Legend does well it does brilliantly. Really brilliantly, and it deserves to be seen on a big screen where it will do the astounding visuals justice. Unfortunately, ultimately, I think the movie fails. You might love it while you watch it, but without giving away anything, I think you will find yourself having several of those "Refrigerator moments" you hear about. That is when you can enjoy a story while you're watching it but later, when you go to make yourself a sandwich that night or the next afternoon, you open the refrigerator door and you suddenly go, "But that doesn't make sense. How could she...? Wait a second...." That is when the movie will begin to unravel.
What is great about I Am Legend is Francis Lawrence's directing and Will Smith's acting. The movie is so tense you can't turn away from it even during some of the most horrifying scenes. Lawrence, who also directed Constantine, pulled out all the stops here. Will Smith is incredible and there's one scene that's a long close-up of him that will wrench your heart. This may be his best performance ever. The special effects are remarkable. And the scenes of a post apocalyptic New York City are breath-taking. Unfortunately, what is ultimately not great about I Am Legend are the last 30 minutes or so. Refrigerator moments aside, the movie was so good that it hurts that it ends so poorly. Yes, I recommend seeing it, just to be blown away by some of the scenes, but I truly wish this one was better.
It came so close.
SWEENY TODD
This is a pretty simple review. Johnny Depp as Sweeny Todd is great. Helena Bonham-Carter as Mrs. Lovett is great, Alan Rickman as Judge Turpin is great. In fact, the entire cast is wonderful with special kudus to Sacha Baron Cohen as Signor Adolfo Pirelli. So is Tim Burton's directing, the script by John Logan based on the Stephen Sondheim musical and everything else from the almost black and white cinematography to the impeccable set design to the powerful and cinematic choreography. This is not a filmed Broadway stage show but a unique movie that needs to be seen whether or not you have seen the original. The movie is funny, horrifying, shocking and great. No negatives.
Johnny Depp's voice is perfect for the role. His voice is clear and unwavering, and completely in tune, but the strength of his singing is in his acting which makes his singing riveting. Although Bonham-Carter's voice is less assured, the range of her songs is greater than I think she can deliver, once again her acting make them work. This is another well-deserved success for Tim Burton.
Labels: Movies